The Year is now 2025 and the informational landscape has shifted drastically. There was a time not too long ago that the only question you had about someone’s blog, article or book was whether they wrote it with original ideas or stole the ideas from someone else. Now that question is murkier. We now ask, did someone or something write it and to be more precise, even if they did, was it generated by a machine and edited by a human or written by a human and edited by a machine?
The real question if we are being honest with ourselves is this: Does it even matter if it was assisted or generated?
Clearly the first items to discuss given the proposed question of this post are; what are the definitions of AI Assisted and AI Generated? For this i plugged the question directly into Chat GPT and the answer it gave were as follows:
AI-Assisted: Content, work, or decisions that are created with human input and guidance while using AI as a tool to enhance, refine, or accelerate the process. The human remains the primary creator, using AI for support in tasks such as editing, brainstorming, drafting, or automation.
AI-Generated: Content or work that is primarily or entirely created by AI with minimal to no human intervention. The AI independently produces text, images, code, or other outputs based on a given prompt or dataset.
The definitions show that the key distinction between the two rests on the level of human input and involvement of the work output. with Assisted works, humans remain primarily in control and Generated works relying mainly on AI to assume the responsibility of the work product.
When and why does it matter?
Below are some quick bullet points of when it is generally accepted to use, avoid and why for various forms of work and creative endeavors.
Academic & Research Work
- Use AI Assisted for brainstorming, organizing etc, but your research and findings should be your own thoughts.
- Avoid AI Generated because many research elements are not accurate as well as hallucinations that AI is known for can cause inaccurate or unverified conclusions.
- Why it Matters: Most Academic Institutions prohibit AI Generated work that isn’t disclosed.
Professional Writing & Journalism
- Use AI Assisted for grammar, some research as long as accuracy is verified
- Avoid AI Generated with sensitive information, especially items that may cause legal issues
- Why it Matters: Journalists in theory require accountability, credibility and oversight.
Creative Writing & Content
- Use AI Assisted for writer’s block, or refining ideas while using your own style and uniqueness
- Use AI Generated for drafts, concepts or sketches but refine and edit to make it your own
- Why it Matters: Readers want to know that they are reading a unique work and creation out of the mind of the author.
Legal/Business Documents
- Use AI Assisted for drafting preliminary contracts or summaries that comply with legal standards and is thoroughly reviewed and fact checked by a lawyer.
- Avoid AI Generated because AI can’t guarantee the accuracy of a legal document and pulls information from many sources that are either old law or bad law. Also some clauses drafted are unenforceable.
- Why it Matters: Legal errors can have catastrophic consequences for clients and can lead to ethical issues and possible disbarment for lawyers.
Marketing/Branding
- Use AI Assisted for ideas, and strategy ideas but refine for brand synergy
- Use AI Generated for media posts, descriptions of products etc.
- Why it Matters: AI lacks brand nuance and the human feel that goes into creating a personal touch.
Code/Software Development
- Use AI Assisted for generating repetitive code and assisting with security features etc.
- Use AI Generated for simple code and scripts but refine and review for errors
- Why it Matters: AI code contains security risks and requires human validation.
There are many sites online now claiming they have the best AI detector out there and that their programs can identify the precise amount of AI used or not used. However, false positives are common on these sites thus human oversight and improved methods to distinguish between AI Assisted and Generated content is still needed.
In Summary, Using AI Generated and, to a lesser extent, AI Assisted content requires human discretion as we move in this new digital world. Only the author truly knows how much use of AI they have incorporated. When using primarily AI Generated content it is the responsibility of said author to disclose that use.
Disclaimer
THE INFORMATION CONTAINED IN THIS WEBSITE IS PROVIDED FOR INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY, AND SHOULD NOT BE CONSTRUED AS LEGAL ADVICE ON ANY MATTER.
The transmission and receipt of information contained on this Web site, in whole or in part, or communication with Zamani Thomas PA via the Internet or e-mail through this website does not constitute or create a lawyer-client relationship between us and any recipient. You should not send us any confidential information in response to this web-page. Such responses will not create a lawyer-client relationship, and whatever you disclose to us will not be privileged or confidential unless we have agreed to act as your legal counsel and you have executed a written engagement agreement with Zamani Thomas PA. The material on this website may not reflect the most current legal developments. The content and interpretation of the law addressed herein is subject to revision. We disclaim all liability in respect to actions taken or not taken based on any or all the contents of this site to the fullest extent permitted by law. Do not act or refrain from acting upon this information without seeking professional legal counsel.